Cremo
Spice & Black Vanilla
“Spicebomb's sweeter, gentler sibling — all the warmth, half the bite.”
Cremo's flagship Reserve Collection entry and one of the best-selling men's fragrances at Target and Walmart — the cult-favorite 5 drugstore dupe. A cardamom-tobacco-vanilla composition widely regarded as a close Spicebomb Extreme dupe.
The take
What works
- ●Cardamom-tobacco-bourbon vanilla at $22 is absurdly good value
- ●Softer, more vanilla-forward than Spicebomb — accessible spicy warm
- ●Widely available at Target and Amazon — no hunting required
Trade-offs
- ●Needs 5+ sprays to register — designed for liberal application
- ●Cardamom can read sharper than Spicebomb's polished version
More from Cremo
Notes
Top
Mid
Base
Performance
Fit
Best in fall and winter, at night. Leans masculine.
When
- Spring, 25%
- Summer, 9%
- Fall, 94%, best
- Winter, 100%, best
- Day, 59%
- Night, 80%, best
Occasions
Gender
Smells like
Similar scent DNA — if you own one, you may not need the other
- Very close
V&R
Spicebomb Extreme
- Very close
V&R
Spicebomb
- Close
Histoires de Parfums
1899 Hemingway
Initio
Rehab
V&R
Spicebomb Eau Fraiche
Tom Ford
Tobacco Vanille
CH
212 Sexy Men
PdM
Herod
Armani
Stronger With You Intensely
Mercedes
Mercedes Benz Club Black Eau de Toilette
Lattafa
Al Awsaaf
Bvlgari
Man in Black
Armani
Stronger With You Tobacco
Essential
Divine Vanille
The Merchant of Venice
Arabesque
Mercedes
Mercedes Benz Club Black Eau de Parfum
You might also like
Popular with fans of Spice & Black Vanilla
JPG
Le Male Le Parfum
Afnan
9PM
Mercedes
Mercedes Benz Club Black Eau de Toilette
Versace
Eros EDT
Lattafa
Khamrah
JPG
Le Male Elixir
V&R
Spicebomb Extreme
Lattafa
Asad EDP
Versace
Eros Flame
YSL
La Nuit de L'Homme EDT
Montblanc
Explorer
YSL
Y Eau de Parfum
Prada
L'Homme
Versace
Dylan Blue
D&G
The One EDP
Dior
Sauvage EDT
Versace
Pour Homme
Rasasi
Hawas EDP
Armaf
Club de Nuit Intense Man EDT
Nautica
Voyage
Featured in
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Cremo Spice & Black Vanilla a good Spicebomb Extreme dupe?
81% similarity to Viktor & Rolf Spicebomb Extreme in our database — a real match, not just shared notes. At $15–$30 vs Viktor & Rolf's $110–$155, it's one of the closer budget interpretations of that DNA.
What does Cremo Spice & Black Vanilla smell similar to?
Closest matches in our database: Viktor & Rolf Spicebomb (82%), Histoires de Parfums 1899 Hemingway (81%), Initio Rehab (63%). Close siblings — adjacent compositions in the same family.
How long does Cremo Spice & Black Vanilla last?
4–6 hours on most skin (good longevity) with noticeable sillage.
When should you wear Cremo Spice & Black Vanilla?
Cremo Spice & Black Vanilla is best in fall and winter, at night. It suits date nights and nights out.
Is Cremo Spice & Black Vanilla worth it?
At $15–$30, yes for this tier. Cardamom-tobacco-bourbon vanilla at $22 is absurdly good value. Softer, more vanilla-forward than Spicebomb — accessible spicy warm.