Best Good Girl Fragrances

The original Good Girl is still the one everyone means. An almond-and-coffee opening over a big tuberose-and-jasmine heart, resting on a tonka-cacao-and-vanilla base — it's the sweet-but-dark contrast that made the stiletto bottle a phenomenon. Sensual, a little dangerous, unmistakably it.

It's a strong evening performer that projects and lasts. At $95–$200 it's the stiletto bottle everyone pictures, and the one to buy first. See the full breakdown.

Supreme deepens the formula with a jammy forest-fruits-and-Egyptian-jasmine opening over a rich tonka-and-tuberose heart, grounded by vetiver. It's fruitier and more intense than the original, the most opulent member of the family and a cold-weather standout.

It's a powerhouse — a little goes a long way. It's the pick when you want Good Girl richer and louder. See the full breakdown.

Very Good Girl trades the coffee-almond darkness for bright red fruit — a litchi-and-red-currant opening over rose, on a vanilla-and-vetiver base. It's the flirtier, more playful spin, sweeter and more approachable than the original while keeping the sultry drydown.

It works day or night and reads younger than the original. At $130–$170 it's the pick for anyone who finds the original too heavy. See the full breakdown.

Good Girl Blush is the soft, daytime member — a bergamot-and-bitter-almond opening over a peony-and-ylang heart, on a light vanilla-and-coumarin base. It drops the dark coffee-cacao side for something bright and floral, the most office-friendly and warm-weather-wearable of the line.

It's easy and approachable rather than a statement. At $85–$120 it's the everyday, lighter version of Good Girl. See the full breakdown.