“Niche price, crowd-pleaser soul — the PdM everyone can get behind.”
Often described as 'Batman would wear this' — Quentin Bisch's 2015 PDM entry sits in the brand's most mysterious corner. A dark, spicy, sandalwood-anchored gourmand with green apple-saffron-nutmeg top, a warm tonka-osmanthus-davana-rose heart, and a rich vanilla-patchouli-opoponax base.
The take
What works
- ●Apple-rose-oud combo that's genuinely elegant, not trendy
- ●PdM's most approachable niche entry point despite the oud
- ●Excellent cold-weather longevity
Trade-offs
- ●Oud note is restrained — purists may want more barnyard character
- ●Steep price for what is essentially a luxe accessible scent
More from Parfums de Marly
Notes
Top
Mid
Base
Performance
Fit
Best in fall and winter, at night. Leans masculine.
When
- Spring, 37%
- Summer, 9%
- Fall, 88%, best
- Winter, 100%, best
- Day, 44%
- Night, 88%, best
Occasions
Gender
Smells like
Similar scent DNA — if you own one, you may not need the other
- Very close
Borouj
Perlador
- Close
CH
Mystery Tobacco
- Close
Mancera
Red Tobacco
$135–$200
- Close
Hugo Boss
Bottled Absolu
$130–$145
- Close
Mancera
Red Tobacco Intense
$185–$235
- Close
Argos
Triumph Of Bacchus
- Close
T. Terenzi
Arrakis
Alexandria
Hafez 1984
Lattafa
Asad Elixir
Bvlgari
Le Gemme Orom
CH
Nightfall Patchouli
Fr. Avenue
Ighwa By Night
Dossier
Lost Americana
Xerjoff
Ivory Route
Alhambra
Sceptre Oceana
Lattafa
La Collection D'antiquités 1910
PdM
Habdan
Dior
Spice Blend
You might also like
Popular with fans of Carlisle
PdM
Layton
Tom Ford
Noir Extreme EDP
PdM
Oajan
Tom Ford
Oud Wood EDP
Tom Ford
Tobacco Vanille
By Kilian
Angels' Share
PdM
Herod
V&R
Spicebomb Extreme
PdM
Pegasus
MFK
Grand Soir
Xerjoff
Naxos
Initio
Oud for Greatness
Nishane
Hacivat
Creed
Aventus
Prada
L'Homme
Amouage
Reflection Man
PdM
Percival
YSL
La Nuit de L'Homme EDT
Initio
Side Effect
Dior
Homme Intense
Featured in
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Parfums de Marly Carlisle smell similar to?
Closest matches in our database: Borouj Perlador (89%), Carolina Herrera Mystery Tobacco (75%), Mancera Red Tobacco (69%). Strong DNA matches — same scent family and similar composition.
How long does Parfums de Marly Carlisle last?
8–10 hours on most skin (excellent longevity) with heavy sillage.
When should you wear Parfums de Marly Carlisle?
Parfums de Marly Carlisle is best in fall and winter, at night. It suits date nights, nights out, and special occasions.
Is Parfums de Marly Carlisle worth it?
At $390–$530, yes for this tier. Apple-rose-oud combo that's genuinely elegant, not trendy. PdM's most approachable niche entry point despite the oud.